Westchester County is home to a vibrant network of thrift shops, many of them volunteer-run and community-supported. These stores are often hidden gems and are stocked with everything from vintage clothing and home décor to furniture and one-of-a-kind finds.
Because many operate on limited schedules, it’s always smart to check hours ahead, but that’s kind of part of the charm. Thrifting here feels like being “in the know.”
Tarrytown & Sleepy Hollow Area (Don’t Skip These!)
This is a small and mighty thrifting pocket and is perfect for a walkable afternoon.
- The Cherry Door Thrift Shop
📍 36 Main St, Tarrytown, NY
A true local gem—volunteer-run and benefiting Phelps Hospital. Expect everything from vintage housewares to furniture.
🕒 Tues–Fri 12–3 PM; Sat 12–4 PM - Trilogy Consignment
📍 54 Main St, Tarrytown, NY
More curated than a traditional thrift with elevated resale, vintage, and artisan goods.
🕒 Mon–Sat ~11–6; Sun ~12–5 - Pretty Funny Vintage
📍 80 S Broadway, Tarrytown, NY
A fun, funky vintage shop with personality, less “thrift,” more retro treasure hunt.
(Bonus: These are all within walking distance which is a bit rare for Westchester.)
Southern Westchester
Mamaroneck & Harrison
- St. Thomas Episcopal Thrift Shop
📍 168 W Boston Post Rd, Mamaroneck, NY
Wed & Sat 10 AM – 1 PM (closed July–Aug) - All Saints’ Second Chance Thrift Shop
📍 222 Sound Beach Ave, Harrison, NY
Tues & Sat 10 AM – 2 PM (Sept–June)
Scarsdale & Rye
- Hitchcock Presbyterian Thrift Shop
📍 6 Greenacres Ave, Scarsdale, NY
Mon 10 AM – 12:30 PM - Rye Presbyterian Thrift Shop
📍 882 Boston Post Rd, Rye, NY
Thu 10 AM – 1 PM (donations Wed/Thu mornings)
Larchmont
- Golden Shoestring
📍 211 Boston Post Rd, Larchmont, NY
Wed–Sat ~11 AM – 4 PM
Central Westchester
Mount Kisco & Armonk
- TWIGS Thriftree
📍 136 E Main St, Mount Kisco, NY
Tue–Sat ~10 AM – 2 PM - United Methodist / Treasures on Smith
📍 40 Smith Ave, Mount Kisco, NY
Mon & Sat 10 AM – 2–3 PM - Treasures Thrift Shop (St. Stephen’s)
📍 50 Bedford Rd, Armonk, NY
Thu 10 AM – 2 PM; Sat 10 AM – 3 PM
River Towns & Hudson Corridor
Yonkers / Tuckahoe
- Red Door Thrift Shop
📍 100 Underhill St, Yonkers, NY
Varied hours including evenings and weekends - Publisher's Pick: Habitat for Humanity ReStore
📍 470 Nepperhan Ave, Yonkers, NY
Tue–Sat 10 AM – 5 PM; select Sundays
Great for furniture and home renovation finds
Verplanck & Garrison
- St. Patrick’s Thrift Shop
📍 137 1st St, Verplanck, NY
Mon, Wed, Sat mornings - That Nothing Be Lost Thrift
📍 82 1/2 Main St, Garrison, NY
Wed–Sun 10 AM – 5 PM
Peekskill
- Publisher's Pick: Art Thriftshop | Retake-Remake
📍The Hat Factory
Thursday - Sunday 10 AM - 4 PM Donations by appointment
Check out a reel spotlight here.
Northern Westchester & White Plains
Katonah
- Katonah Thrift Shop
📍 136 Jay St, Katonah, NY
Thu–Sat 10 AM – 2 PM
White Plains
- St. Bart’s Thrift Shop
📍 82 Prospect St, White Plains, NY
Thu & Sat (call ahead) - St. Gregory Thrift & Gift Shoppe
📍 215 Halstead Ave, White Plains, NY
Thu 12 PM – 4 PM - The Back Door Thrift Shop
📍 175 Bloomingdale Rd, White Plains, NY
Tue–Thu ~10 AM – 2 PM
Yorktown Heights
- Yorktown Love In Action
📍 177 Front St, Yorktown Heights, NY
Typically open ~10 AM – 6 PM (varies)
Pro Tips for Thrifting in Westchester
- Plan around hours: Many are only open a few days a week
- Stack stops geographically (Tarrytown is the best example of this)
- Go often: Inventory turns over quickly
- Ask locals: Some of the best spots are under-the-radar
If you love finding spots like these, you’re exactly why we're here. I’m a local mom who spends my days sharing the best things to do, hidden gems, and family-friendly finds across Westchester, the kind of places and resources you might not stumble on unless someone tells you.
If you want more ideas like this (plus events, guides, and things to do each week), I’d love to have you join us.
👉 Subscribe for free here and stay in the know with Westchester families
