articles

Penny Lick Ice Cream Celebrates 10 Sweet Years in Hastings

Hosting a 10-year anniversary party with a special flavor and fundraiser for Hastings SEPTA

By Kelly Fitzpatrick and Kate Schlientz August 22, 2025

HASTINGS ON HUDSON, NY –  Penny Lick Ice Cream, the beloved local scoop shop renowned for its all-natural, nut-free ice cream, is thrilled to announce its 10th anniversary in Hastings on Hudson. To commemorate this milestone anniversary, Penny Lick Ice Cream is hosting a celebratory event for the community at its original Hastings on Hudson location (580 Warburton Avenue) on Saturday, September 20th, from 12:00 PM to 5:00 PM. The festivities will be packed with family-friendly activities, including face painting, a flavor naming contest, and a craft station. 
The event also serves as a scoop-a-thon—a portion of the proceeds of all sales benefits the Hastings on Hudson Union Free School District's Special Education Parent Teacher Association (SEPTA). SEPTA works to support students, families, and staff as they partner on both educational and recreational initiatives. They provide parent education programming and serve to inform the community of new regulations and district initiatives.

In honor of the anniversary, Penny Lick is introducing a special, limited-edition flavor that pays homage to Hastings’ rich history. The new flavor, a pavement grey ice cream made with charcoal and a rich caramel swirl, ties into two important parts of the village’s past—the sugar refineries and the renowned Hastings marble and pavers. The shop is holding a naming contest for this unique flavor, and the winner will receive a special "Everything But the Scoop" party pack, valued at $85.

“We are incredibly grateful for the unwavering support we’ve received from the Hastings on Hudson community and beyond over the past ten years,” said Ellen Sledge, owner of Penny Lick Ice Cream. “When we opened, our goal was to create a space where everyone, especially those with nut allergies, could enjoy delicious, high-quality ice cream in a safe and welcoming environment. It has been a true joy to become a part of the fabric of this community, and we are incredibly excited to have expanded our reach to Mamaroneck and Ossining, allowing us to share our passion for great ice cream with even more people."


The opening of the Mamaroneck location in 2023 marked a significant step for Penny Lick, providing a state-of-the-art factory to support the growing demand for their ice cream, both at their shops and at private and public events. The Ossining waterfront location, which opened in 2024, further solidifies Penny Lick’s commitment to serving the local area and creating vibrant community spaces. Penny Lick Ice Cream has cultivated a loyal following through its unwavering commitment to using only the finest ingredients, crafting unique and nostalgic flavors, and maintaining a strictly allergy-friendly environment across all its locations (peanut, tree nut, and sesame-free). The shop’s dedication to quality and community has earned it numerous accolades and a special place in the hearts of residents throughout Westchester County.
The 10th-anniversary celebration in Hastings-on-Hudson is not only a thank you to the loyal customers who have supported Penny Lick from the beginning but also an opportunity for the community to celebrate the brand's growth and continued commitment to the region.

About Penny Lick Ice Cream 
Founded in 2013, Penny Lick Ice Cream is a small-batch, artisanal ice cream company committed to producing 100% nut-free ice cream using all-natural ingredients. What began as a sweet offering at local farmers markets, the original Hastings on Hudson ice cream shop has expanded to include a second location with a dedicated factory in Mamaroneck (est. 2023) and a third waterfront location in Ossining (est. 2024). Penny Lick continues to offer a rotating selection of classic and inventive flavors, remaining dedicated to providing a safe and joyful ice cream experience for all.